Areas where food production was high were more likely to have developed a writing system. Societies that developed writing were able to advance quicker than societies that didn't, and it gave a significant advantage because those with writing abilities could gain knowledge of other civilizations and record it.
Further on in the book, particularly in Chapter 17, Diamond examines and compares the development of Austronesians to the people of New Guinea. Again reiterating the importance of environment, Diamond states that the Austronesians and the New Guineans came from a common set of ancestors yet developed differently in different regions. They each made use of the best things they could find in their environment. Also, Diamond shows how each culture adapted to their environment and how these adaptations either helped or hurt them in the long run.
The advantages that each of the cultures had more or less out weighed each other, and when the Austronesians attempted to invade New Guinea, they found they had little to no advantage and instead decided to co exist. One major difference in the way that Diamond presents the world's history is that he centers so whole heartedly on environment, ecology and location as a dominant factor that he tends to forget about other contributors to societal development. Traditions seems to give a more broad, all encompassing tale of world history.
Instead of focusing primarily on one factor, it instead incorporates different factors and summarizes how they all tie in together. Different world leaders, world powers, wars, technological development, and agricultural development are all touched upon in Traditions and explored to the fullest, whereas they are briefly mentioned if at all in Diamond's Guns.
- NPR Choice page!
- persuasive essay on cloning humans!
- writing a teacher resume and cover letter!
- esl argumentative essay topics?
- "Collapse" by Jared Diamond.
- essay on why you should respect your elders;
This is also Diamond's major flaw. He seems to be very narrow minded and wants very badly to prove his point that environment is the deciding factor in how a society or civilization develops. Each book poses varying yet similar accounts of history as a whole. Jared Diamond tends to be a bit one sided while the text book is a bit more broad.
Each has its strengths and weaknesses. Each argument is persuasive in and of itself.
'Guns, Germs, and Steel' Reconsidered
Finding a medium between the two is difficult, but if one can appreciate that each is telling the same story of history from a different perspective which often happens , then one can take each for what they are worth. Guns, Germs and Steel by Jared Diamond is a literary work that details history from an environmental point of view. Each book offers a perspective on history that should not be ignored.
- opinion essay about being famous?
- Guns, Germs, and Steel.
- from great paragraphs to great essays 3.
- Guns Germs Steel.
- Navigation menu;
What one chooses to take out of each is up to the individual themselves. I am choosing to believe pieces of each text, because as George Santayana said, "History is always written wrong, and so always needs to be rewritten. Ziegler, and Heather E. New York: McGraw-Hill, Diamond, Jared. Guns, Germs and Steel. New York, London: W. Many students who come to our site want to know how fast we can deliver a completed paper to them. They then go on reassuring a stressed-out student that indeed, our service can deliver high-quality works within a matter of several hours.
There is, of course, a limit on the number of pages even our best writers can produce with a pressing deadline, but as a rule, we manage to satisfy all the clients seeking urgent help. It is a common practice to charge more for such immediate papers, and our company is not an exception. However, you can be sure that you are getting a fine work for the price you are paying.
Jared Diamond Confidential Reflections on Writing, Science, and Life
Online academic help is a solution many students use to save their time, their place, and their grades. We successfully deal with any challenges you may ask us to help with, and there are various services we provide to our students. On our site, homework help implies more than simply writing a paper from scratch. Your work will be thoroughly checked to contain no plagiarism and accompanied by reference and title pages.
Guns, Germs And Steel Essay
While you pay for homework, we offer those options for free. Additionally, you can order editing and proofreading. You can also get various discounts on our site which will help you save some more money for future orders or whatever you want to spend them on. Our customer support will gladly tell you whether there are any special offers at the moment, as well as make sure that you are receiving the best service our company can deliver.
Homework for me One-stop solution for students in need of homework help. Order now Get a Quote. Why choose our homework help? Because we know exactly what matters most to you.
Guns, Germs, And Steel
Leave all papers to us and rest! Free Revisions. If you feel that your paper could use more work, send it for a free revision. On-time Delivery. Deadlines are sacred for our writers, with them you will never miss the submission date.
In the book Guns, Germs, and Steel by author Jared Diamond, he uses the thesis that geography is a major issue to why some societies flourished, and others did not. This can be evaluated by looking at the many civilizations in the past at different geographical locations such as Europe, and Latin America. The first situation that is brought up is about New Guinea, which Diamond finds his friend Yuri asking him about cargo.
He states a conclusion that in Europe, the types of animals, native plants, and east to west geographical orientation provide better enhancement of the growth of a civilization. A variety of animals played a role due to domestication, and uses for mundane activities. European civilizations and societies also experienced a different weather climate than that of New Guinea or even the Latin Americas. While Europe sees four seasons of different kind of climates, places like New Guinea and the Latin Americas do not. Places like Mesopotamia and New Guinea both experienced unreliable weather where droughts and floods could kill crops, animals, and capital.
The advantage that these two places had however was the access to river or water sources, which in Europe were difficult.